Key takeaways
- Pick by the reason you are leaving: a free barcode scanner, nutrient detail, adaptive targets, photo logging or less searching.
- MyFitnessPal puts its barcode scanner and data export behind Premium; Cronometer, MyNetDiary and FatSecret list a scanner on their free plans.
- Cal AI has belonged to MyFitnessPal since the acquisition announced on March 2, 2026.
- MyFitnessPal’s Nutrition Coach cannot log food or edit goals, according to its own help page.
- Lose It! Premium is now listed at $79.99 a year, and its barcode scanner is moving to Premium.
- IZeat logs a meal from one sentence in your assistant and shows the source of every figure, but it has no scanner, no history import and no micronutrients.
Which MyFitnessPal alternative fits your reason for leaving?
The best MyFitnessPal alternative depends on why you are leaving. For a free barcode scanner, look at Cronometer, MyNetDiary or FatSecret. For nutrient detail, Cronometer. For targets that adjust every week, MacroFactor. For the same kind of diary, Lose It!. For photo logging, Cal AI, now owned by MyFitnessPal.
How I compared them. I used MyFitnessPal, Lose It!, Cal AI and YAZIO myself. For every app, I read prices and plan details on the publisher’s own pages and on the US App Store on October 6, 2026. This is not a timed or accuracy test, and no app is ranked by weight lost. IZeat is my product: we publish this page and sell one of the options below. Prices vary by country, store and offer.
| App | Pick it if you are leaving MyFitnessPal because… | Free plan | Paid price (US$, list) | Barcode scanner on the free plan | One limit |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| MyFitnessPal (baseline) | You are not leaving: the large database is what you need | Food and exercise logging, macros, own recipes, measurements | Premium $19.99/month or $79.99/year | No, Premium only | Data export and macro goals in grams are Premium |
| Lose It! | You want the same kind of diary | Calorie budget and its 50M+ food database | Premium $79.99/year; Lifetime $299.99 | Being moved to Premium in 2026 | Same search-and-pick logging as MyFitnessPal |
| Cronometer | You want nutrient detail and your raw data | Lab-analysed data, custom foods, export of all raw data | Gold $10.99/month or $59.99/year | Yes | Ads on Basic; charts limited to a 7-day window |
| MacroFactor | You want targets that adjust every week | None; 7-day trial | $11.99/month, $47.99/6 months or $71.99/year | No free plan | Paid only |
| YAZIO | You want fasting plans and recipes | Diary, daily analysis, 16:8 fasting | PRO $23.90 to $47.90 for 12 months (App Store) | Listed; check your account | Recipes and weekly analysis are PRO |
| FatSecret | You want a free diary that still scans | Diary, scanner, food photo recognition, weight tracker | Premium $10.49 to $14.99/month or $38.99 to $59.99/year | Yes | Paid features are mostly meal planning |
| MyNetDiary | Ads and sign-up walls are the problem | Diary, scanner, voice logging, 108 nutrients, no ads | Premium $8.99 to $59.99 depending on term | Yes | Meal Scan and adaptive targets are Premium |
| Cal AI | You want to log from a photo | None for scan results; 3-day trial | “Unlimited” plans $2.99 to $29.99, periods not stated | No free plan | Owned by MyFitnessPal since 2026 |
| IZeat | Searching for every item is what wore you down | None; 7-day trial without a card | €19.99/month or €99.99/year (euros) | No scanner at all | Needs an assistant that supports MCP connectors |
If the paid scanner is why you are leaving, Cronometer, MyNetDiary and FatSecret list one on their free plans; MacroFactor, Cal AI and IZeat have no free plan.
Sources, all read on October 6, 2026: MyFitnessPal plans and App Store listing, Lose It! membership tiers, Cronometer plans and Gold, MacroFactor, YAZIO PRO and App Store listing, FatSecret, MyNetDiary and Cal AI App Store listings, and IZeat’s pricing.
What changed at MyFitnessPal in 2026, and when should you stay?

MyFitnessPal Free still logs food and exercise, shows macros and lets you create foods, meals and recipes. Its plan comparison (updated October 5, 2026) puts the barcode scanner, Meal Scan, macros in grams, ad-free use and data export behind Premium, listed at $19.99 a month or $79.99 a year on the US App Store, with cheaper offers alongside.
- A new layout. A Today tab replaced the previous dashboard, according to MyFitnessPal’s help page on the new app experience (updated September 15, 2026).
- An AI Coach that cannot log food. Nutrition Coach answers questions from your diary, but MyFitnessPal’s own help page (updated October 2, 2026) says it cannot log food or edit your goals. A meal it suggests still goes into the diary by search, barcode, Meal Scan or voice. Coach is for Premium and Premium+ members on iOS, in English, in six countries.
- Cal AI joined the group. MyFitnessPal announced on March 2, 2026 that it had acquired Cal AI. The deal closed in December 2025, and Cal AI runs as a standalone app with access to MyFitnessPal’s database, according to TechCrunch.
What wore me down: MyFitnessPal is a search-and-pick diary. Searching the food database by hand for every item took far too long.
Stay on MyFitnessPal if you scan most of your packaged food and already pay for Premium, if you rely on years of history and device sync, or if the database suits you. Leaving makes sense when one specific thing no longer works for you, and the sections below are organised by that reason.
Lose It!: is it the closest replacement for MyFitnessPal?

Lose It! suits someone who likes MyFitnessPal’s kind of diary and wants another one. Lose It! Basic is free, with a personal calorie budget and a 50M+ food database. Premium costs $79.99 a year and adds barcode scanning, photo and voice logging, nutrient goals and device sync; Lifetime is a one-time $299.99 (membership page, updated September 9, 2026).
The price changed in 2026. Many earlier reviews quoted $39.99 a year, and an App Store price tracker recorded the $39.99 “year of premium features” item being removed on March 25, 2026. Lose It! is also moving its barcode and label scanner to Premium: some free members keep it during the transition, others do not (help page updated April 1, 2026).
My limit with it: Lose It! is the same kind of app as MyFitnessPal. I still searched the food database by hand for every item, and that took far too long.
Cronometer: which app if you want nutrient detail and your raw data?

Cronometer suits people leaving because they want more than calories and macros, or because MyFitnessPal’s export is paid. Its free Basic plan has no time limit and includes nutrition data from lab-analysed sources, custom foods and recipes, activity-tracker sync and export of all raw data (subscription types, updated October 5, 2026). The barcode scanner is in both plans, and Gold costs $10.99 a month or $59.99 a year (Gold page, checked October 6, 2026).
One limit: Basic shows ads and limits reports and charts to a 7-day window. Gold removes the ads, opens any time frame and adds photo logging. I have not used Cronometer; this comes from its own pages.
MacroFactor: which app if you want targets that adjust?

MacroFactor suits people leaving because MyFitnessPal sets a target once and leaves it there. MacroFactor adjusts calorie and macro targets every week from your logged intake and weight trend, and logs by search, barcode, nutrition label scan or AI photo (official page, checked October 6, 2026). It costs $11.99 a month, $47.99 for six months or $71.99 a year after a 7-day trial.
One limit: there is no free plan, by design. If price is your reason for leaving, MacroFactor solves a different problem. I have not used it; this comes from its own page.
YAZIO: which app if you want fasting plans and recipes?

YAZIO suits people who want a diary with fasting timers and a recipe library. The free app includes the diary, daily analysis and the 16:8 fasting plan. YAZIO’s 3,000+ recipes, the other fasting plans, weekly and monthly analysis, AI photo tracking and ad-free use are PRO (app tutorial, PRO features, both updated October 2026).
The US App Store listing shows PRO at $23.90 or $47.90 for 12 months, among other terms, and names a barcode scanner under the free calorie counter (checked October 6, 2026). Check in your own account whether scanning stays free.
My limits with it: in my use, the food database was entered by users, so entries were unreliable. Portions were badly estimated, and exercise calories were over-counted.
FatSecret: is there a free diary that still scans barcodes?

FatSecret suits people leaving over price who still want to scan packaged food. Its US App Store listing presents the app as free and lists a food diary, barcode scanner, photo recognition of foods, exercise diary, weight tracker and macro reports. Premium adds dietitian meal plans, advanced meal planning, six extra meal headings and water tracking, with items from $10.49 to $14.99 a month and $38.99 to $59.99 a year (checked October 6, 2026).
One limit: FatSecret’s paid features are mostly about planning, so it changes little if logging speed is your problem: you still search, scan or photograph each food. I have not used it; this comes from its listing.
MyNetDiary: which app if ads and sign-up walls are the problem?

MyNetDiary suits people leaving over ads and paywalls. Its US App Store listing promises no ads and no account required, and lists a free barcode scanner, voice logging, macro tracking and 108 nutrients. Meal Scan, adaptive calorie targets, intermittent fasting and Fitbit, Garmin or Withings sync are Premium. Premium items range from $8.99 to $59.99 depending on term, and Premium Plus, which adds an AI Coach, is listed at $14.99 (checked October 6, 2026).
One limit: adaptive targets cost extra here. MyNetDiary also publishes its own MyFitnessPal comparison and speed test, so read its accuracy and tap-count claims as the publisher’s. I have not used it; this comes from its listing.
Cal AI: is photo logging the answer?

Cal AI suits people who want to point the camera at a plate and get calories and macros back. Food-scan results require a subscription, according to its App Store listing, which shows “Unlimited” plans from $2.99 to $29.99 without stating their periods; its site mentions a 3-day free trial and says Cal AI is “about 80% accurate” (checked October 6, 2026). Check the price in the app before you subscribe.
Cal AI belongs to MyFitnessPal. The acquisition was announced on March 2, 2026, and Cal AI now draws on MyFitnessPal’s database (TechCrunch). If the company is why you are leaving, Cal AI keeps you with the same owner.
My limit with it: Cal AI was far too approximate for me. It had no idea of the ingredients’ macros, nor whether I had used oil or anything else.
IZeat: what if searching for every item is what wore you down?
IZeat is the five-star chef calorie tracker that suggests satisfying, great-tasting meals, so you enjoy every calorie you have left. It works inside ChatGPT, Claude or any other assistant: IZeat knows your numbers for the day, which foods fill you up and what you like. You connect it once to an assistant that supports MCP connectors, then describe a meal in one sentence. IZeat records it and returns the meal, the day’s totals and what is left against the targets you chose.
“Lunch: 180 g grilled chicken breast, 150 g cooked rice and a 125 g pot of plain yoghurt.”
Ask what to eat next and your assistant reads what is left of your day from IZeat, then suggests a filling meal that fits. The suggestion is the assistant’s, and nothing is logged until you say what you actually ate. In my own use, logging this way is about 10x faster than searching a conventional tracker; that is my observation, not a timed average.
Every figure shows where it came from: a nutrition label you photographed, a number you gave, a reference value for a plain weighed food, or a marked estimate. IZeat does not claim to be more accurate than the apps above; what it changes is that an estimate is never presented as a measurement. For a plate photo, IZeat’s instructions make the assistant ask about weight, cooking method, cooking fat and sauces before it estimates, the questions Cal AI never asked me. The assistant can still misjudge a portion, and you can correct the meal in the same conversation.
- IZeat has no barcode scanner and no food database of its own: you photograph the nutrition label, give the numbers or describe the food.
- IZeat cannot import your MyFitnessPal history, so keep your MyFitnessPal export.
- IZeat records calories, protein, carbohydrate and fat, with no micronutrients.
- IZeat needs an assistant that supports MCP connectors, such as ChatGPT or Claude; the connection guide lists the steps. The assistant’s own subscription, if any, is separate.
IZeat costs €19.99 a month or €99.99 a year, after a 7-day free trial without a card. See the current price.
How do you switch from MyFitnessPal without losing your history?
- Export your MyFitnessPal data while you still have Premium. Data export is a Premium feature; going back to Free keeps your logs in the account, but not the export.
- Write down your calorie and macro targets so you can set the same numbers in the new app.
- Log one familiar day in the new app, including cooking oil and sauces, then correct one item. Check that the day total makes sense to you.
- Before paying, check the renewal price and how to cancel. Cancel the old subscription once the new diary works for you.
For the full exit sequence, read how to export a food diary before leaving a tracker. To compare free plans in more depth, see which free calorie counter includes the features you need; for photo and AI logging, the AI calorie tracker comparison; for adaptive targets and macro goals, the macro tracking app comparison.
Frequently asked questions
Short answers to the questions people type, each one sourced above.
Is Cal AI or MyFitnessPal better?
Neither wins on every count, and both belong to the same company since MyFitnessPal’s acquisition of Cal AI, announced on March 2, 2026. Cal AI is built for photo logging; MyFitnessPal for searching and scanning a large database. In my use, MyFitnessPal’s manual search took far too long, and Cal AI’s photo estimates were far too approximate, with no idea of the ingredients or the oil. Pick the method whose weakness you can live with.
Is MyFitnessPal still the best?
MyFitnessPal still has one of the largest food databases, about 20 million foods according to its owner, and a free diary that logs food, exercise and macros. It is no longer the obvious choice if you want a free barcode scanner, a free data export or an AI that logs for you: the first two are Premium, and its Nutrition Coach cannot log food. Which app is best depends on which of those you need.
Is there a better free app than MyFitnessPal?
For a free barcode scanner, yes: Cronometer, MyNetDiary and FatSecret list a scanner on their free plans, while MyFitnessPal keeps it for Premium (checked October 6, 2026). Cronometer Basic also exports all your raw data, and MyNetDiary’s listing promises no ads. MacroFactor, Cal AI and IZeat are not free alternatives: they offer a trial, then a subscription. See what free gets you in a calorie tracker.
What is the best free app for food tracking?
The best free food tracker is the one whose free plan covers your routine. For scanning packaged food, Cronometer, MyNetDiary and FatSecret include a scanner without paying. For nutrient detail and a full export, Cronometer Basic. For a diary without ads or an account, MyNetDiary, according to its listing. MyFitnessPal Free still logs food and macros if you search by hand. After any trial, check what stays free.
Does MyFitnessPal’s AI Coach log food for you?
No. MyFitnessPal’s help page, updated October 2, 2026, says Nutrition Coach cannot log food: if it suggests a meal, you add it to the diary yourself by search, barcode, Meal Scan or voice. It cannot edit your goals either. Coach is for Premium and Premium+ members on iOS, in English, in the US, the UK, Ireland, Canada, Australia and New Zealand.
Can I bring my MyFitnessPal history to IZeat?
No. IZeat does not import a MyFitnessPal diary. Export your data from MyFitnessPal before you cancel Premium, because export is a Premium feature, and keep that file. IZeat starts a new diary from your first described meal; your old history stays in your export and in your MyFitnessPal account.